Manitowoc has the largest market share, as of this posting, with over 40% of the US market in commercial ice maker sales. It's obvious why, as they lead with the highest quality and longest lasting ice machine on the market. Although typically priced slightly higher than Hoshizaki or Scotsman, the savings pays off over the life of the machine. Manitowoc is easier to work on, costs less to maintain, and generally lasts longer than other ice maker manufacturers.
Commercial Ice Machines |
Scotsman is the 3rd largest player in the commercial ice maker market. They offer a quality machine at a discounted price, by providing machines on a slightly lower quality grade, with a lower price point. Their latest series of ice maker, known as the Prodigy, aims to combat the perceived lower quality by using technology pioneered by Manitowoc. Scotsman ice makers are also known to be much more energy efficient than their Hoshizaki competitor machines.
Overrall, going with any of he big 3 manufacturers of commercial ice makers will guarantee you have a good ice machine for your needs. However, in terms of quality and reliability, Manitowoc has far and away passed the competitive field, so if you can spend a little more money, go with the Cadillac and buy Manitowoc.